Shingles vs. Tile Roofing – Which Is Best?

Shingles vs. Tile Roofing

When building a new house or replacing the roof on your home, you will be faced with the decision of which material to use. If you are torn between shingles and tiles, the question “Which is best?” can only be answered through careful consideration of the pros and cons. Every household will have a different answer to this question, and they can reach a resolution by turning to trusted “roofers near me” for valuable information and advice about which material will best suit the home. When choosing between materials that are so different in price, function, and longevity, it is helpful to see how both measure up in these important areas. In the next few paragraphs, we will take a look at some of the most important considerations to see how each material measures up. 


One of the most important considerations for homeowners when replacing a roof is the price of installation. Asphalt shingles are by far the most affordable material, even when compared to other materials such as metal and wood. You can expect to pay between $350-$700 per square for quality shingles. Concrete tile roofing can cost between $550-$700 per square, and clay tile can cost up to $1,800 per square. 

Our choice for affordability: Shingles


When installed by reputable roofing contractors, both asphalt shingles and tiles can last for many years. However, tiles, whether concrete or clay, can be expected to last longer. Shingles have an average lifespan of around 25 years, although they can last up to 50 years in certain climates and with the proper roof maintenance. However, clay tiles can last anywhere from 50 to 100 years, so they are a more long-term investment.

Our choice for longevity: Tiles


Asphalt shingles are often favored for the simplicity of their installation. Shingles are easy to cut to size, making them a good choice for roofs with unique shapes. Because they are easy to install, this reduces the cost of labor and often makes for a faster process. Clay tile roofing and concrete tiles can be difficult to install and easy to get wrong. They require a high degree of experience and skill, so the installation should only be done by a contractor with a reputation for tile roofing installation. 

Our choice for the installation process: Shingles


Both shingles and tiles are low maintenance and don’t require a lot from homeowners. However, an occasional roof inspection can help you be proactive in caring for your roofing system, and prevent any serious damage before it occurs. However, shingles can degrade over time as a result of moisture, wind, and even sunshine. Homeowners may need to occasionally replace shingles or repair small leaks. Tile roofs are one of the easiest to maintain, and will only need to be washed occasionally to keep them clean and beautiful, as well as the occasional tile replacement for broken tiles. 

Our choice for maintenance: Tiles


Shingles are made from an extremely light material that is still fire-resistant and able to keep moisture away. They are perfect for homes that don’t have a solid enough structure to support a heavy roof. Tiles are heavy, so they can only be installed on homes that can withstand this additional weight. 

Our choice for weight: Shingles


Tiles and shingles can both be very durable choices, especially when installed with care. However, hail, changing temperatures, and other types of severe weather can cause shingles to disintegrate, crack, or fall off. A shingles roof can also be subject to rot and mold growth. A tile roof is one of the most durable materials because it cannot rot, it is resistant to UV rays, and it is one of the most fire-resistant materials.

Our choice for durability: Tiles

Types of Roofs

When you are choosing a material for your new roof, the style and color of your roof can also be an important consideration. Thankfully, both types of roofs come in almost every imaginable color giving you endless combinations to compliment your home’s architectural style and the color of the walls. Shingles can mimic other materials such as wood and stone, and tiles can be mixed and matched for a truly unique design. 

Our choice for style: Both

Every home is unique and every family has different priorities. If you value affordability over longevity, you may find yourself gravitating towards asphalt shingles. Shingles are a timeless solution that will serve your home well for many years. If you value the low maintenance and durability of tiles, you may be willing to pay more to have long-term peace of mind. Choose the material that best suits your needs, and then find a quality contractor to get the job done right. 

Your Above & Beyond Team of Professional Roofers

In the market for a new roof in the Houston, TX area? Precision Roof Crafters has been serving home and commercial business owners in the entire Houston area since 1996. Our team of roofing experts can’t wait to serve you! Give us a call, or send us a message today to learn more about how Precision Roof Crafters can help you. We are above and beyond the team.


You may also like

What Are Roof Ridges?

What Are Roof Ridges?

What Types of Roofs Are There?

What Types of Roofs Are There?
{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}